The Importance of Checking Encapsulated Banknotes Before Buying: A Complete Guide for Collectors

In the fascinating world of banknote collecting (paper numismatics), certification by companies like PMG (Paper Money Guaranty) and PCGS (Professional Coin Grading Service, which also certifies banknotes) has revolutionized the market. These services encapsulate banknotes in protective capsules (slabs) and assign a numerical grade that reflects their condition, facilitating transactions and increasing trust. However, not everything is as secure as it seems . Many collectors make the mistake of buying without physically verifying the banknote inside the capsule, relying solely on the label. This can lead to unpleasant surprises: banknotes that don't match the description, inflated grades, or signs of tampering.

In this updated article, we'll explore why it's essential to check encapsulated banknotes when buying , the risks of not doing so, real-world examples of discrepancies between PMG and PCGS, how to check correctly, what to do if the grading seems incorrect (including claims to grading houses for possible compensation), and a key proposal for greater transparency: the open publication of photos of all graded banknotes.

1. Why are banknotes encapsulated and what are their advantages?

The encapsulation (slabbing) protects the banknote from environmental damage such as humidity, dust, or direct tampering. The capsule is sealed in such a way that any attempt to open it leaves visible evidence (tamper-evident). Furthermore:

  • Authenticity guaranteed (in most cases).
  • Objective grading on a scale of 1 to 70 (70 = Perfect Gem Uncirculated).
  • Increased liquidity : Certified tickets sell faster and at better prices.

PMG and PCGS are world leaders. PMG, part of the Certified Collectibles Group (along with NGC), specializes in banknotes. PCGS, famous for coins, has expanded its service to include banknotes with similar standards.

But the capsule isn't foolproof. The following can happen:

  • Swapping (changing one banknote for a lower-value one).
  • Crack-out and resubmit (extraction and resubmission to improve grade).
  • Subjective discrepancies between services.

2. The Hidden Risks in Encapsulated Banknotes

Buying a slabbed ticket without physical inspection is risky. Some common dangers:

  • Label does not match banknote : The serial number, signature or date on the label does not correspond to the visible banknote.
  • Undeclared damage : Creases, stains, or restorations that the graduation does not adequately reflect.
  • Inconsistent grades : The same banknote can score 35 in PMG and 64 in PCGS (or vice versa).
  • Post-certification manipulation : Some collectors remove the banknote, "improve" it, or forward it.
  • Online fraud : Counterfeit slabs or altered banknotes on eBay, forums or auctions.

According to numismatic forums and communities, PCGS tends to grade similar banknotes higher than PMG (up to 10-15 points difference in extreme cases), due to slightly different criteria in centering, eye appeal or handling of restorations.

3. Real-World Examples of Discrepancies in Graduations (Based on Common Cases)

Many collectors have documented cases where the same banknote changes grade when going from PMG to PCGS or when being sent back to be graded:

  • Belgian Congo 10 Francs (1943-45) : A banknote overprinted with "Troisième Émission - 1943" scores 30 or 35 in PMG (Very Fine/Choice Very Fine), but 64 (Choice Uncirculated) in PCGS after possible tampering or resubmitting. The difference is drastic: from VF to CU.

  • Uruguay 5 Pesos (1930) : PMG or independent services give 15 (Fine), but later PMG or PCGS reaches 40 (Extremely Fine).

  • India 1000 Rupees (1937) : PMG 45 (Choice Extremely Fine), but PCGS raises it to 55 (About Uncirculated).

  • Cameroon 500 Francs (1962) : PMG 58 (Choice About Uncirculated), PCGS 64 (Choice Uncirculated) or even 67 Superb Gem.

  • Egypt 5 Pounds (1940-45) : PMG 55 (About Uncirculated), PCGS 64 (Choice Uncirculated).

  • British Caribbean 2 Dollars (1954-60) : PMG 53 (About Uncirculated), PCGS 64 (Choice Uncirculated).

  • Austria 1000 Schilling (1954) : PMG 64 (Choice Uncirculated), PCGS 68 PPQ (Superb Gem).

These cases illustrate how subjectivity in evaluation (centering, paper quality, eye appeal) creates differences. A "manipulated" banknote (cleaned, pressed, or reshipped) can increase dramatically in value.

4. How to Properly Verify the Banknote Inside the Capsule

Don't rely solely on the label. Follow these steps:

  1. Verify the certification number online :
  2. Visually inspect :
    • Compare the serial number visible on the banknote with the one on the label (it must match exactly).
    • Check signatures , dates , watermarks and designs against references (Pick catalog).
    • Use bright light (flashlight or UV light) to detect hidden damage: creases, stains, repairs, or if the banknote seems "loose" in the capsule.
    • Observe the overall appearance : Does it match the prescription? A 64 should look almost perfect, with no visible creases.
  3. Look for signs of manipulation :
    • Irregular edges on the capsule.
    • Bubbles or separation in the seal.
    • Misaligned label or defective printing.

If something doesn't look right, don't buy it or ask for more photos/details.

5. What to do if the denomination seems incorrect or the bill does not match?

If you suspect an error:

  • Contact the seller : Demand a refund or negotiation.
  • File a complaint with the certifying body :
    • PMG Guarantee : Covers authenticity and ensures the banknote is not overgraded. If overgrade or alteration is determined, they offer: re-encapsulation to the correct grade and payment of the difference, purchase of the banknote at the fair price, or replacement. Send for an "Appearance Review" (free) with receipts. Does not apply to Net grades (only genuine banknotes). Details: https://www.pmgnotes.com/paper-money-grading/pmg-guarantee
    • PCGS Banknote Guarantee : Covers grade and authenticity (with a 1% premium). Does not cover "Details" grades (only genuine). Claim if there is a serious discrepancy.

In practice, many discrepancies do not generate automatic refunds (subjectivity), but compensation is possible if there is evidence of error or manipulation.

6. Proposal for Greater Transparency: Public and Searchable Photos of All Graded Banknotes

One of the biggest current limitations of the certification system is the lack of open and filterable access to images of certified banknotes. Currently, both PMG and PCGS allow verification of a specific certificate number and, in some cases, display a photo of the associated banknote (front and back). However, there is no public database where anyone can search and view photos of all graded banknotes , filtering by banknote type (pick number), issuer, date, signature, partial serial number, denomination, or even population by grade.

If certification bodies implemented this functionality—for example, an advanced search engine similar to Population Report but with images visible for all certificates—the market would be much more transparent . The benefits would be enormous:

  • Immediate detection of swapping or fraud : By comparing the official photo of the certificate with the actual banknote in the capsule, it would be easy to identify if someone has changed the contents.
  • Post-grading tamper control : If a resubmitted banknote drastically changes grade, the historical photo would help to track alterations.
  • Greater confidence for buyers : You could check before bidding in auctions or buying in forums if the banknote matches certified examples of the same type and grade.
  • More effective cheating : Collectors and the community would detect patterns of abuse (multiple suspicious resubmits, systematic discrepancies) and pressure the certifiers to take action.

This measure would not only reduce fraud but also raise the ethical standards of the hobby. Currently, owner privacy and technical issues are cited as barriers, but with anonymization (without displaying personal data) and intelligent filters, it would be feasible and beneficial for everyone. It's an improvement the numismatic community has been demanding for years and would make the market fairer and safer.

7. Tips for Buying Certified Tickets Safely

  • Buy from reputable auctions or dealers with a money-back guarantee.
  • Prefers sellers with positive feedback.
  • Use escrow or PayPal Goods & Services to be protected during your purchase.
  • Investigate population (PMG Population Report) to see if the grade is common.
  • Consider cross-grading (sending to the other company) if you have any doubts.
  • Avoid offers that are "too good to be true".

Verification is your best protection – and transparency, the future.

Encapsulated banknotes offer security, but they don't replace personal inspection . Checking the banknote inside the capsule, comparing it to the label, and filing a claim if necessary can save you significant losses. Discrepancies between PMG and PCGS are common and sometimes the result of tampering. Be proactive: use online verification tools, inspect the banknote under light, and if something seems off, walk away or file a claim.

Furthermore, the proposal to make photos of all certified banknotes publicly available and searchable would be a revolutionary step toward full transparency, making it easier to catch fraudsters and protecting honest collectors. Until that change comes, the responsibility lies with us.

Have you experienced a similar discrepancy, or do you think certification bodies should implement public photos? Share in the comments. If you're a collector, subscribe for more guides on secure numismatics!

Images provided by my friend Lin, an expert in French-style colonial banknotes and the best banknote detective I know. Perhaps one day he'll write on this blog. :)

Back to blog